On a recent visit to New York City and the bustling metropolis that is Manhattan, Wendy and I decided to see if we could avoid giving money to the global High Street brands in favour of more local, independent stores. We have always been fans of the conveniently-placed Starbucks; especially when visiting the USA, but after reading an article about how Starbucks coffee shop domination was forcing hundreds of independent coffee houses to close, while at the same time reducing the choice we have as consumers and standardising tea & coffee so much that we can’t ask for a medium coffee anymore - it has to be a ‘Grande’; we decided to see if we could get through a 4-day visit without giving in.
At the same time we decided to avoid all of the franchise stores, the big chains and the global High Street brands such as McDonalds, Burger King (who have a company policy in Manhattan to mistrust their customers by only accepting bills up to $20) and Subways (although it really is hard to live without those Italian meatball subs!). Broadly speaking it was not difficult to find a good, local, independent alternative to these franchise-based stores, although it is surprising how many you have to walk past to locate an ‘Indy’. In Manhattan at least, the quality was high and the choice was wide, although prices were never cheaper than the global conglomerates.
In avoiding ‘buying into’ these stores, we can claim a very small victory, but have to admit that in the grand (or the Grande) scheme of things, these brands are exploiting brand to dominate markets and if the average ‘Indy’ store had the sort of backing that the big boys have; they’d be doing exactly the same. So, from our point of view, this wasn’t a hippy protest again globalisation (although we do believe its gone too far) but rather an experiment to see if it was possible.
What wasn’t possible was to avoid Coca Cola & Pepsi. Even if their lead brands were dodged, getting around without drinking something disguised as something else but then finding that it’s owned by Coca Cola or some other huge global drinks maker is very difficult indeed. There are also some brands that we would not want to avoid, such as a bottle of Bud or a the subject of many a mid-night snack a packet of Lays potato chips. Nevertheless the main object of the test was to avoid Starbucks and in that we can claim absolute success. More power to the independent coffee shop!
Before leaving this subject, one positive point to make about the big High Street brands or the renown/well-known food brands that you might find in a supermarket, such as Heinz Baked Beans or Cadbury’s Dairy Milk.
Even if we are trying to avoid buying them, we still all recognise them and actually use them as reference points. You know that you are on a main street if you see a McDonalds and a Pizza Hut vying for your trade. If you are walking around a supermarket for instance, you are much more likely to navigate yourself around the aisles following visual clues such as leading brands, rather than signage. You recognise that you are in the baked bean aisle because you see the Heinz tin; even if you then search around for a store own-brand or a lesser-known cheaper or more expensive brand.
The next time you visit a large City, try to avoid the franchise-type stores and find a local alternative. By giving your money to an independent store rather than a global brand, you might just contribute to a slight redressing of the balance that has recently been lost. We’re not saying boycott these stores forever; just give it a go and see if you can!